|Anonymous | Login | Signup for a new account||2019-08-23 18:22 PDT|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Roadmap | Summary | My Account|
|View Issue Details|
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0007828||opensim||[REGION] OpenSim Core||public||2016-02-13 07:05||2019-02-06 11:30|
|Product Version||master (dev code)|
|Target Version||Fixed in Version||master (dev code)|
|Summary||0007828: Seated vehicle should not be autoreturned if vehicle owner/group doesn't match current parcel owner/group|
|Description||Seated vehicles are being auto returned when the vehicle owner/group differs from the parcel owner/group. The right behaviour would be for the vehicle to auto return only when its driver stands up from the vehicle in such a parcel.|
|Steps To Reproduce||1) Make a seperate parcel, set its autoreturn to 1 minute. Deed the parcel to a group|
2) Rez a vehicle outside the just created parcel, set the vehicle to a different group than the parcel just created
3) Drive the vehicle into the newly created parcel
4) Wait a minute while staying seated
|Additional Information||In SL, a vehicle would also be auto returned also in the following cases:|
* When trying to enter a parcel that has no public access (banlines)
* When the parcel doesn't have enough free prims to hold the entering vehicle
This is not of primary importance but maybe worth mentioning. They are also annoyances of the vehicle community (pilots, sailors etc).
A common use case of this bug report could be a racetrack sim with public rezzing and short autoreturn as seen in SL. People can then rez their own car/bike and race as long as they don't standup (and then some minutes depending on the autoreturn value).
|Git Revision or version number||OSgrid 0.9.0.0 (Dev) b34652e: 2016-01-26 (Unix/Mono)|
|Run Mode||Grid (Multiple Regions per Sim)|
|Environment||Mono / Linux64|
|Attached Files|| 00-no_autoreturn_on_object_owner_seated.diff [^] (1,071 bytes) 2016-06-28 20:21 [Show Content]
01-no_autoreturn_on_any_avi_seated.diff [^] (1,303 bytes) 2016-07-03 13:30 [Show Content]
I worded this bug too difficult, it can be easier titled as:
'Bug: Foreign seated(!) object gets auto returned'
Whether a vehicle or a static object (like a chair), a seated object should NOT be auto returned, even if it is not owned by the land owner/group.
The object should ONLY be auto returned if the avatar stands up AND the object has been there longer than the parcel auto return time.
In SL this can be tested: in any open-to rez parcel you don't own, rez a chair and sit out the parcel auto return time. Notice how you can sit as long as you want. When standing up some time after the auto return time has expired, notice how the chair is neatly auto returned.
|Included patch brings auto return in line with SL. Please review and test :)|
Actually, in SL the object stays as long as ANY avatar sits on it, not just its OWNER so my version is a bit more tight (secure?).
To have it 100% SL compatible, the object should be checked against ANY avatar sitting I think by iterating over the avatars in the scene and doing the same check, unless there is a more straightforward way.
But this is already very usable :) What lead to me reporting this bug is because I wanted to create public rez zones for people to rez their vehicles on my sims to then drive around and explore by car. Similar like you see on SL mainland.
edited on: 2016-07-03 13:48
OK now with diff 01 made it 100% SL compatible; it works exactly the same now as per SL spec. The attached diff 01 supersedes the older diff 00
Tested with parcel owned by avatar A, with auto-return 1 minute and rez allowed:
* Avatar B rezzed 2 cubes
* Avatar B and avatar C sat on cubes
* Avatar B and avatar C were able to remain seated indefinitely
* The moment avatar B and avatar C stood up, the boxes were auto returned (to avatar B) as avatar A owns the land and the boxes were foreign objects.
Test successful :)
[09:58] <cia-opensim> opensim: ajlduarte * r11a8a722df89 OpenSim/Region/Framework/Scenes (SceneObjectGroup.cs): don't auto return objects if they have sitting avatars (not npcs) - mantis 7828 with diferent code
sorry I didn't use your code but thx
Gavin Hird (reporter)
|This can also be used for squatting / harassment, so any object should be auto returned after the timeout. For roads the owner usually will set the auto return timeout to a reasonable number.|
Ubit: Cool, much better code but why no NPCs? I guess no sim tours by a NPC bus/train/ferry/airballoon driver then or is that a fringe case.. (no prob I can always 'patch the patch' for my own use ;) Can't NPC's cross sims borders? I never tried.
Gavin: The change makes it functionally equal to how it works in SL. Reproduce my test (note 30861) in SL (in a SL rez zone with 10 minute autoreturn for example). I can't think of any case that this would lead to bad things as long as either auto return or no entry is used wisely.
In the case of a squatter, they would have to remain seated on the object for as long the land is to be occupied. The moment he/she stands up, then poof gone is the object. I only know of some rare times where aircraft carriers do this on the Blake Sea to have a mobile base where aircrafts land, and that's more roleplay than griefing.
no NPCs can't cross borders, and NPCs could eventually hold a object "forever" and potentially aggravate the "squatter" problem.
the pros and cons of this are open to debate (not much the NPCs case ;) )
in last case this can be made a option, but we have so many of those that I would like to avoid it.
Gavin Hird (reporter)
In SL I've had a squatter who was there for weeks on end off of a public road. Did not do any harm, but could easily have.
I have also had people launch griefing off of the SLRR track using this "feature". Not everything is optimal as it is implemented in SL.
Configurable might make sense.
|Marked as Resolved but never closed, can be reopened if needed.|
|2016-02-13 07:05||Lotek||New Issue|
|2016-02-13 07:12||Lotek||Tag Attached: Vehicles|
|2016-02-13 07:12||Lotek||Tag Attached: autoreturn|
|2016-06-28 01:54||Lotek||Note Added: 0030806|
|2016-06-28 20:21||Lotek||File Added: 00-no_autoreturn_on_object_owner_seated.diff|
|2016-06-28 20:23||Lotek||Note Added: 0030830|
|2016-06-28 20:23||Lotek||Status||new => patch feedback|
|2016-06-28 20:58||Lotek||Note Added: 0030831|
|2016-07-03 13:30||Lotek||File Added: 01-no_autoreturn_on_any_avi_seated.diff|
|2016-07-03 13:43||Lotek||Note Added: 0030861|
|2016-07-03 13:47||Lotek||Note Edited: 0030861||View Revisions|
|2016-07-03 13:48||Lotek||Note Edited: 0030861||View Revisions|
|2016-07-08 02:00||UbitUmarov||Note Added: 0030881|
|2016-07-08 02:53||Gavin Hird||Note Added: 0030882|
|2016-07-08 03:34||Lotek||Note Added: 0030883|
|2016-07-08 03:42||UbitUmarov||Note Added: 0030884|
|2016-07-08 03:54||Gavin Hird||Note Added: 0030885|
|2016-07-08 07:44||Lotek||Status||patch feedback => resolved|
|2016-07-08 07:44||Lotek||Fixed in Version||=> master (dev code)|
|2016-07-08 07:44||Lotek||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2016-07-08 07:44||Lotek||Assigned To||=> Lotek|
|2019-02-06 11:30||BillBlight||Note Added: 0034520|
|2019-02-06 11:30||BillBlight||Status||resolved => closed|
|Copyright © 2000 - 2012 MantisBT Group|